Ecclesiastes 9:17-18 meaning

Verses covered in this passage:

  • Ecclesiastes 9:17
  • Ecclesiastes 9:18

Trying to control others through shouting and coercion is destructive while quiet words of wisdom are more powerful than weapons of war.

Solomon now tells us the words of the wise heard in quietness are better than the shouting of a ruler among fools. A ruler has positional authority. Someone who can yield coercive power over others. A ruler might use shouting to express their positional power. But Solomon makes it clear that positional power is an inferior form of power. What some call referent power is superior. Referent power is influence gained through respect.

The superior power Solomon advocates appears as words heard in quietness. Contrasting with the shouting of a ruler, the words of the wise are heard not because they are required to be heard, as with a ruler, but because those hearing the words of the wise recognize their benefit and choose to listen. Accordingly, those who hear the words of the wise are wise themselves. As opposed to the fools who are directed by the shouting of a ruler.

Solomon comments further on the words of the wise vs. the coercive power of the ruler. He asserts that wisdom is better than weapons of war. This is another way to assert that the referent power of the words of the wise heard in quietness is superior to coercive power.

However referent power is not always used for good. One sinner destroys much good. Just as the referent power of the wise can do much good, the referent power of the sinner can lead many astray. When people are led astray, their actions result in destruction. Romans, Chapter 1, tells us that when anyone chooses sin by following their own fleshly lusts, God “gave them over” to their own lusts, leading to destruction. This is called the “wrath of God” against unrighteousness.

Biblical Text:
17 The words of the wise heard in quietness are better than the shouting of a ruler among fools.18 Wisdom is better than weapons of war, but one sinner destroys much good.

Check out our other commentaries:

  • Colossians 1:3-8 meaning
    The unifying power of the gospel brings believers together, from Paul to Colossae to the ends of the earth.......

  • Romans 13:3-5 meaning
    The government is meant to make laws that punish evil actions. If we want to feel safe in our country, we should obey the laws.......

  • Genesis 9:5-7 meaning
    God makes a new rule that murder of another human being shall require their life. God also instructs for Noah to populate the earth abundantly......

  • Matthew 7:15-20 meaning
    Jesus gives His disciples a warning against false prophets and a test for unmasking them.......

  • Deuteronomy 17:2-7 meaning
    Moses describes the method of administrating justice when Israel enters Canaan, the Promised Land, in the case of someone who has transgressed God’s covenant by......