John 20:19-20 meaning
The parallel account of John 20:19-20 is Luke 24:36-49 and possibly 1 Corinthians 15:5b.
In John 20:19-20, the risen Jesus appears to His fearful disciples on the evening of His resurrection, proves that He has risen bodily from the dead by showing them His wounds, and replaces their fear with joy and peace.
The Gospel of John records the first and the last of the five times that Jesus appeared on the day of His resurrection.
- Mark and John record Jesus's first appearance after His resurrection to Mary Magdalene.
(Mark 16:9, John 20:11-18) - Matthew records Jesus's second appearance to the women returning from the tomb.
(Matthew 28:8-10) - Luke and Paul mention Jesus's third appearance which was to Simon Peter.
(Luke 24:34, 1 Corinthians 15:5a) - Luke records Jesus's appearance to the two disciples on the road to Emmaus.
(Luke 24:13-32) - Luke and John record Jesus's final appearance on the day of His resurrection to the disciples hiding in Jerusalem.
(Luke 24:36-43 (or Luke 24:36-49) and John 20:19-23)
The Bible Says commentary of John's account of Jesus's fifth appearance is divided into two parts: His sudden appearance and His disciples' reaction (John 20:19-20), and Jesus's message to them (John 20:21-23).
For a more complete listing of the Biblical record of Jesus's post-resurrection appearances, see The Bible Says article: "How Many Times Did Jesus Appear After His Resurrection?"
In the previous section, John described Jesus's first appearance to Mary Magdalene outside the garden tomb (John 20:11-18). Mary Magdalene returned to tell the disciples what she saw and relayed Jesus's message to them (John 20:18).
John's relative silence about the disciples' response and what follows in this passage, John 20:19 in particular, indicate that the disciples as a whole were rather dismissive of Mary's joyful announcement. Mark is more explicit. He reveals that the disciples did not believe Mary's report (Mark 16:10-11). John now speaks of Jesus's fifth appearance on the day Jesus rose from the dead, which was to the hiding disciples:
So when it was evening on that day, the first day of the week, and when the doors were shut where the disciples were, for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in their midst and said to them, "Peace be with you" (v 19).
John begins by establishing the timing of Jesus's next appearance.
He establishes that it was late in the day: So when it was evening on that day (v 19).
In the West, we say sundown occurs during the evening. But Jewish days begin and end at sundown. According to their tradition, the new day dawns when the light of the first three stars appear in the evening sky. In a Jewish context, the term evening could mean anything between mid-afternoon (3:00pm and beyond) and when it is dark and the new day has begun. Without any additional context, evening could mean either the next day, or it could mean that same day.
John provides additional context to clarify which day it was. John says what follows occurred when it was evening on that day. The expression that day means that same day. So, John clarifies that it was not yet tomorrow, but it was still the same day that:
- Mary saw the empty tomb
(John 20:1-2) - Peter and John investigated and confirmed the tomb was empty and saw Jesus's grave-clothes
(John 20:3-10) - Jesus appeared to Mary
(John 20:11-17) - Mary announced to the disciples: "I have seen the Lord"
(John 20:18)
John makes it even more clear that what he is about to describe in John 20:19-23 occurred on the same day as the events of John 20:1-18 by adding the expression—the first day of the week. John began this chapter by saying that Mary Magdalene first went to the tomb "on the first day of the week" (John 20:1). Mary first came to the tomb early on that day before sunrise, while it was still dark (John 20:1). Now, it is still the first day of the week but it is evening and late on that day and the sun is getting ready to set.
After establishing the time as evening on that day, John then describes the location and mood of the disciples: and when the doors were shut where the disciples were, for fear of the Jews (v 19).
The disciples were the followers of Jesus, including members of His twelve core disciples who are named in Matthew 10:2-4. At least two of these twelve disciples were not present for this occasion. The two disciples who were definitely not present were Judas, who betrayed Jesus and had recently killed himself (Matthew 27:3-5) and Thomas, who for some undisclosed reason happened to not be there (John 20:24).
Peter also may have been absent because apparently some time between Mary's encounter and this moment, Jesus had also appeared to Peter (Luke 24:34, 1 Corinthians 15:5). Because this group of disciples appears to highly doubt Jesus's resurrection at this point, it seems unlikely that Peter would still be doubting Jesus's resurrection after encountering Jesus alive.
In his parallel account, Luke explains "the eleven and those who were with them" were gathered there (Luke 24:33). So, when Luke writes "the eleven," he is generically describing the remaining core disciples (minus Judas), and he is not being specific that every single one of eleven remaining disciples were present.
The "those who were with them" whom Luke mentions (Luke 24:33) included the two disciples who met Jesus unknowingly on the road to Emmaus, before recognizing Him and returning to the eleven (Luke 24:13-35).
One of these two disciples "was named Cleopas" (Luke 24:18). Cleopas and the other unidentified disciple had just arrived from Emmaus (about seven miles away—Luke 24:13) to report to the eleven "their experiences on the road and how [Jesus] was recognized by them in the breaking of the bread" (Luke 24:35).
"Those who were with them" (Luke 24:33) might also have included any number of the following people:
- The female disciples, Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James the less, Salome the mother of James and John, and/or other women who closely followed Jesus and who were present for the events surrounding Jesus's death, burial, and resurrection.
(Matthew 27:56 28:1, Mark 15:40, 15:47, 16:1, Luke 23:55, 24:10, John 19:25) - The two men who were close followers of Jesus from the beginning who were put forward as candidates to replace Judas as one of the twelve. These men were "Joseph called Barsabbas (who was also called Justus), and Matthias" (Acts 1:23).
(Acts 1:21-26)
The disciples' mood was fearful and confused.
John describes the disciples as hiding for fear of the Jews.
When John uses the term the Jews, he often means the Jewish authorities, the Sanhedrin Council consisting of the chief priests, elders, and scribes and the Sanhedrin's proxies—the temple guard and their agents and allies. However, "Jews" is also used to refer to all of Israel, as in John 4:22 where John records Jesus as saying "salvation is from the Jews" referring to the nation as a whole. So, as is the case with most words, context is key. In this case it is clear that John refers to the Jews who posed a threat to their physical safety, which would refer to the same Jews who crucified Jesus.
It is likely that all of the twelve disciples other than Judas were from Galilee, in the north, which had been repopulated with Jews during the brief century of independence in the second and first century before Christ under the Maccabees, also called the Hasmoneans. "Jew" was derived from "Judah," one of the twelve tribes of Israel which later became the name for the southern kingdom whose center was Jerusalem. The northern boundary of the historic kingdom of Judea was not many miles north of Jerusalem.
Galilee lay well within the territory of the historic northern kingdom, called Israel—and poetically "Ephraim"—in scripture, whose capital was Samaria. So, it is likely that the term "Jews" had tribal, geographic, as well as political roots, since Jerusalem was also the seat of Jewish political authority.
It was these specific Jews (and not all Jews) that the disciples were in fear of. The Jewish authorities arrested and condemned Jesus, and the disciples were, reasonably, afraid that they would now come after them.
Mark described the disciples as "mourning and weeping" when Mary first came to tell them that she had seen the Lord (Mark 16:10).
The disciples' fear, as described by John, indicates that they did not believe Mary's report that Jesus was alive. Instead of believing Mary, the disciples seem to have believed that the religious authorities were not finished trying to eradicate Jesus and His movement even though they had already had Him crucified. The disciples seem to have still believed that the Jews were the ones who secretly stole Jesus's body and were now possibly trying to find the disciples' location to arrest them.
The disciples may have suspected and been fearful that the Jews were trying to set a trap. They might have thought the Jewish authorities had secretly removed Jesus's body and opened His tomb in order to lure the disciples out of hiding to investigate or even publicly proclaim that Jesus had risen from the dead. Once the disciples came of out hiding, the authorities could arrest and imprison them and produce Jesus's body to put an end once and for all to the Messianic claims surrounding Jesus of Nazareth.
Or perhaps they were concerned that the Jews would accuse them of stealing the body and use that as an occasion to convict them. It would be very human for them to have many disaster scenarios fueling their fear. The disciples' fearful skepticism that Jesus rose from the dead is in harmony with Mark's account, which explicitly says the disciples did not believe Mary's announcement that Jesus had risen (Mark 16:10).
The disciples' location was somewhere in Jerusalem (Luke 24:33, 36). It was enclosed because the doors were shut. It was also inside (John 20:26).
The disciples' location was possibly the large, furnished upper room where Jesus had led their Passover Seder before His betrayal and arrest (Mark 14:15, Luke 22:12). The Bible does not identify the room where the disciples gathered in John 20:19, but it would have made sense for them to return to this familiar and private location in a time of fear. The disciples were from Galilee, not Jerusalem, so the places they could secretly gather together in hiding would have been limited. The disciples also returned to "the upper room" after Jesus's ascension (Acts 1:13).
If the disciples were hiding in the upper room at this moment, then in a span of less than two months this room would have hosted the last Supper, where Jesus first promised to send the Helper to them (John 14:16-17, 25-26), been a place where Jesus appeared to His disciples after His resurrection, and was the location where the disciples received the Helper/Holy Spirit (Acts 2:1-4):
In the upper room, just three days before, Jesus had told the disciples:
"I will not leave you as orphans; I will come to you. After a little while the world will no longer see Me, but you will see Me; because I live, you will live also. In that day you will know that I am in My Father, and you in Me, and I in you."
(John 14:18-20)
And:
"Peace I leave with you; My peace I give to you; not as the world gives do I give to you. Do not let your heart be troubled, nor let it be fearful."
(John 14:27)
Now the disciples were possibly in that exact room where Jesus said these things to them three days earlier, feeling like orphans with troubled hearts, hiding in fear, doubt, and confusion. The disciples were troubled because, despite the reports from Mary Magdalene (Mark 16:9-11, John 20:18) and by this point, probably the other women also (Matthew 28:8-10), they did not yet believe that Jesus had risen from the dead.
As they were afraid: Jesus came and stood in their midst and said to them, "Peace be with you" (v 19b).
John's description of this moment indicates that Jesus's appearance was sudden and unexpected by the disciples. The fact that Jesus came and stood in their midst when the doors were shut (v 19) also indicates that one moment Jesus was not there, then suddenly He was standing there amidst them.
Jesus materially and supernaturally appeared to them in the flesh. This indicates that Jesus's resurrection body had the capacity to transport in a different manner than our current body. Paul calls the resurrection body believers are promised a "spiritual body" contrasting with a "natural body" (1 Corinthians 15:44). This might provide a small hint of the amazing things in store for believers in the world that is to come (1 Corinthians 2:9).
Luke says that Jesus stood in their midst while Cleopas and the other disciple were telling the group of disciples about their encounter with Jesus on the road to Emmaus (Luke 24:36).
The expression Jesus greets them with: "Peace be with you" is likely a translation of the common Hebrew greeting: "Shalom." Even though the Gospel of John was published in Greek, Jesus predominantly spoke in Hebrew and/or Aramaic. (See The Bible Says article: "The Four Languages of Jesus's Judea"). Therefore, when Jesus greeted His disciples "Peace be with you," He most likely said: "Shalom."
While "shalom" is often translated as peace, its meaning is much richer than the absence of conflict. The Hebrew word "shalom" carries the idea of wholeness, completeness, well-being, harmony, and flourishing. "Shalom" describes the condition of life as God intended it to be—a life marked by right relationships with God, with others, and within oneself. Thus, when Jews greet someone with "shalom" they are wishing God's blessing, well-being, and wholeness upon them.
In this context, Jesus's greeting was far more than a customary salutation. His disciples had been shattered by His arrest, crucifixion, and death. They were fearful, grieving, confused, and burdened with guilt for abandoning Him. By saying, "Shalom," the risen Jesus was announcing that through His death and resurrection He had restored what had been broken. True Peace and wholeness ("shalom") were now theirs because Jesus restored the fellowship that had been broken between God and humanity since Adam's disobedience; Jesus did this by fulfilling the Law, overcoming sin, death, and the world by trusting God.
Luke also writes when Jesus appeared and stood in their midst that He said to the disciples "Peace be with you" (Luke 24:36).
In saying "Peace be with you" to His frightened disciples, Jesus was comforting them and letting them know that they had nothing to fear or be afraid of, because He was alive and they were not alone. The assurances that He had made to the disciples three nights earlier (John 14:18-20) and the promise of peace instead of trouble and fear (John 14:27) were being fulfilled in the presence of the risen Jesus standing in their midst.
Luke adds when the disciples saw Jesus standing there among them that "they were startled and frightened and thought that they were seeing a spirit" (Luke 24:37).
At first, Jesus's sudden appearance disturbed the disciples and made them more afraid. It was ironic that Jesus had accomplished true Shalom and was speaking its blessings to His disciples when He said: Peace be with you and their response was to be "startled and frightened" (Luke 24:37).
It was also ironic that even when Jesus finally appeared to them, the disciples still did not believe that Jesus had risen from the dead. Their initial response was to think that they were seeing a disembodied spirit rather than an embodied person. It was apparently more believable to the disciples that they were seeing a ghost, rather than seeing Jesus alive from the dead, as He told them He would do and as Mary (Mark 16:9-11, John 20:18) and the other women (Matthew 28:10), and now Cleopas and another disciple, said they had encountered (Luke 24:35).
Jesus then proved to the disciples that He was truly alive and that He had really risen from the grave.
And when He had said this, He showed them both His hands and His side (v 20a).
By showing His disciples, His hands and His side (v 20), Jesus was showing them that He really was resurrected from the dead. His hands and His side bore the physical scars of His body from His crucifixion. His hands were nailed to the cross, the scars left by those nails were still there. His side was pierced with a spear when one of the Roman soldiers stabbed Him to ensure that Jesus was really dead (John 19:33-34). The scar in His side from that piercing was still there for the disciples to see.
Luke describes how Jesus addressed His disciples' doubts and even invited them to touch Him and see that He was physically alive and not a spirit:
"And He said to them, 'Why are you troubled, and why do doubts arise in your hearts? See My hands and My feet, that it is I Myself; touch Me and see, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have.' And when He had said this, He showed them His hands and His feet."
(Luke 24:38-40)
Jesus let His disciples touch Him and see for themselves that He had physically come back to life from the dead after being crucified. The scars in His hands and feet and side demonstrated that the person standing before them was the same person who had been crucified three days earlier. The same crucified body that laid in the tomb had now been raised back to life. His hands and His side identified Jesus as the crucified Messiah.
The scars showed that Jesus's resurrection was a physical resurrection and not only a spiritual coming back to life.
Jesus's resurrection did not erase the scars of the cross. The scars remain as a reminder of the Son of God and Messiah’s sacrifice that made forgiveness and eternal life possible.
In Revelation, Jesus is worshipped in the throne room of heaven as a sacrificial Lamb who is "standing, as if slain" (Revelation 5:6). Even though the Lamb has been slain and sacrificed, He is standing and alive, just as Jesus was crucified and slain, and now standing amidst His disciples alive, but showing them His crucifixion scars.
Luke also mentions that before at least some of the disciples believed that He had risen from the dead that Jesus also ate some food to demonstrate that He was not a phantom.
"And when He had said this, He showed them His hands and His feet. While they still could not believe it because of their joy and amazement, He said to them, "Have you anything here to eat?" They gave Him a piece of a broiled fish; and He took it and ate it before them."
(Luke 24:40-43)
John writes how after the disciples saw Jesus's hands and His side that they rejoiced at seeing Him alive again.
The disciples then rejoiced when they saw the Lord (v 20b).
The disciples' rejoicing was a fulfillment of what Jesus predicted when He said the disciples would weep and lament but their "grief would be turned into joy" (John 16:20). Jesus compared the disciples' pain-turned-to-joy as a woman in labor who is in pain for a moment, but then rejoices when her child has been born into the world (John 16:21).
"Therefore you too have grief now; but I will see you again, and your heart will rejoice, and no one will take your joy away from you."
(John 16:22)
For the past three days the disciples had been lamenting and grieving Jesus's crucifixion and death, and the mysterious disappearance of His body. Now the disciples were experiencing incredible joy; they rejoiced when they saw the Lord alive standing in their midst (v 20).
The disciples' fear and skepticism strengthen the authenticity and credibility of the Gospels. Rather than portraying themselves as courageous heroes, the Gospel writers honestly depict themselves as frightened, confused, and slow to believe.
The disciples' cowardice and fear is a mark of authenticity of this historical account.
If the disciples had fabricated the resurrection story, it is unlikely they would have portrayed themselves so unfavorably. Ancient biographies and legendary accounts typically exalt their heroes and minimize their failures, but the Gospels repeatedly do the opposite. Throughout the Gospels the disciples are shown:
- Misunderstanding Jesus's teachings
(Mark 8:31-33) - Pettily bickering over who is the greatest
(Luke 22:24-27) - Shamefully falling asleep while Jesus prayed in Gethsemane
(Matthew 26:40-45) - Fleeing in fear when He was arrested
(Mark 14:50), - Denying Him three times, in the case of Peter
(Matthew 26:69-75),
And here, the disciples are hiding behind locked doors in fear while refusing to believe the testimony of those who had already seen the risen Lord (Mark 16:10-11, John 20:19).
Such repeated and unflattering depictions of the Gospel authors and their closest companions are difficult to explain as propaganda, but they are exactly what we would expect from truthful historical accounts that report events as they actually happened.
The disciples' skepticism also strengthens the central claim of Christianity—that Jesus truly rose from the dead.
The disciples were not predisposed to believe in the resurrection, nor were they swept away by wishful thinking or emotional enthusiasm. On the contrary, they were reluctant converts who resisted the testimony of Mary Magdalene, the other women, and even the reports of fellow disciples until they personally encountered the risen Jesus and examined the evidence for themselves. Their belief was not the starting point of the resurrection story, it was the result of being convinced by the risen Christ.
The disciples' initial skepticism creates space for our own questions and investigation. The Gospels do not ask us to believe due to an example of the disciples believing immediately. Rather, the Gospels invite us to consider the same evidence that transformed fearful skeptics into bold witnesses who spent the rest of their lives proclaiming that Jesus had indeed risen from the dead, at the eventual cost of their own lives.
Those of us in this generation have ample evidence to believe. And we are more blessed by believing without seeing. As Jesus will later tell Thomas in this chapter, who was not present at this gathering, "Because you have seen Me, have you believed? Blessed are they who did not see, and yet believed" (John 20:29). There is ample testimony to support that Jesus still appears to people, and they are blessed by believing. But hearing these reliable accounts and believing brings greater blessing.
For more about the all-important claim that Jesus rose from the dead, see The Bible Says article, "Did Jesus of Nazareth Rise from the Dead?"
John continues to describe Jesus's fifth recorded appearance in John 20:21-23, where he reveals what Jesus came to tell them when He first appeared to them as they were hiding in Jerusalem.