Select font sizeSet to dark modeSet to dark mode

John 20:21-23 meaning

John 20:21-23: Jesus's message to His disciples in Jerusalem. In His first appearance to His disciples on the day of His resurrection, Jesus prepared them for what they were going to do, saying, "As the Father has sent Me, I also send you," and breathed on them, telling them to receive the Holy Spirit. He concluded by entrusting them with the authority to proclaim the forgiveness of sins through the gospel, declaring that those whose sins are forgiven are forgiven, and those whose sins are retained are retained. This is Jesus's fifth recorded appearance on the day of His resurrection.

The parallel accounts of John 20:21-23 are Luke 24:36-49 and possibly 1 Corinthians 15:5b.

In John 20:21-23, Jesus commissions His disciples to continue His mission, prepares them to receive the Holy Spirit, and entrusts them with proclaiming the forgiveness of sins through the gospel.

John continues his account of Jesus's initial appearance to His disciples on the day of His resurrection that he first began describing in John 20:19-20.

When Jesus first appeared to His disciples on the evening of His resurrection, they were gathered together behind locked doors for fear of the Jews (John 20:19a). Luke's account of this appearance states that the disciples were in Jerusalem (Luke 24:33). Although the tomb was empty and Mary Magdalene had reported seeing the risen Lord, the disciples did not believe her and remained confused, fearful, and uncertain about what would happen next. Suddenly, Jesus stood in their midst and greeted them with the reassuring words, "Peace be with you" (John 20:19b)

To remove every doubt that He had truly risen bodily from the dead, Jesus showed His disciples His hands and His side (John 20:20). The wounds from His crucifixion confirmed that the One standing before them was the very same Jesus who had been nailed to the cross and was buried three days earlier. Their sorrow, fear, and uncertainty gave way to joy as they realized their Lord was alive, just as He had promised.

Having comforted His disciples and demonstrated that He was alive, Jesus now turned their attention to the work that lay before them. Jesus had recently completed what He was sent to accomplish.

From the cross, Jesus victoriously cried out "It is finished" just before He gave up His human spirit (John 19:30). Now that He was raised back to life from the dead, all that remained was for this Gospel (literally "good news") of what Jesus had accomplished and had made available to the world to be made known to the world.

But Jesus would not be the One to take the Gospel to all nations. Jesus would send His disciples to deliver and spread the good news to the world while He returned to His Father in heaven. They would be asked to do the most important assignment in the world without Him physically by their side as He had been for much of the last three years.

After about forty days Jesus would ascend into heaven (Acts 1:3). This meant that Jesus had little time to prepare His disciples for the mission that lay ahead. In the course of only a few weeks Jesus had to refocus His disciples from the shock of recent events and their own (incorrect) expectations that Jesus would claim and establish His physical kingdom right now (Acts 1:6) so that they would be ready for the incredible responsibilities He was about to entrust to them.

As an aside, it is astonishing the magnitude of the things God entrusts to humans. He entrusted His creation to humanity (Genesis 1:28, Psalm 8:4-8) and He entrusts the furtherance of the Gospel to His disciples. As David exclaims in Psalm 8, it is stunning that God placed humans, who are comparative "infants and nursing babes" above the angels in reigning over the earth.

Then, when humans fell, God sent His Son to die in order to restore humanity's right to reign (Hebrews 2:9-10). Jesus left Heaven to suffer and die as a human for the salvation of the world, and "through the suffering of death" restored being "crowned" with the "glory and honor" of all authority over the earth (Matthew 28:18, Hebrews 2:9, Philippians 2:9-10).

For His own reasons, God entrusts people—humans—to make His costly work known. In the letter to the Romans, through a series of rhetorical questions, Paul asks how people will call on the Lord for salvation if no one is sent to tell them the good news (Romans 10:14-15). Believers are charged with the important task of proclaiming God's most important work and the hope: the Gospel. That is a massive responsibility of everlasting importance.

That passage also asserts that all people have already had the gospel presented to them by God's creation. Romans 10:18 quotes Psalm 19, which asserts that all God's creation speaks testimony of Him continually. Thus, all are without excuse. Notwithstanding this, the work God has entrusted to humans is incredible. He asks us to spread the gospel, make disciples, and learn to be overcomers and possess the reward of our inheritance to have our design restored, and share Christ's authority in His kingdom (Revelation 3:21, Hebrews 2:9-10, Colossians 3:23-24, Romans 8:17b).

Once His disciples finally believed that He truly was raised back to life from the dead (John 20:19-20), Jesus wasted no time in stating the business at hand.

So Jesus said to them again, "Peace be with you; as the Father has sent Me, I also send you." And when He had said this, He breathed on them and said to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained" (vv 21-23).

In this message Jesus blessed His disciples and prepared them for their mission, empowered them to receive the Holy Spirit, and authorized them to share the life-giving Gospel to everyone in the world.

There are four parts to Jesus's message in verses 21-23:

  1. JESUS BLESSES THE DISCIPLES.

So Jesus said to them again, "Peace be with you…" ( v 21a).

  1. JESUS PREPARES THE DISCIPLES FOR THEIR MISSION.

"…as the Father has sent Me, I also send you" (v 21b).

  1.  JESUS EMPOWERS THE DISCIPLES TO RECEIVE THE HOLY SPIRIT.

And when He had said this, He breathed on them and said to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit" (v 22).

  1.  JESUS AUTHORIZES THE DISCIPLES TO SHARE THE GOSPEL.

"If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained" (v 23).

Jesus's message in John 20:21-23 is a prelude to the commissioning He would later give His disciples in Galilee that is typically known as "The Great Commission" (Matthew 28:18-20).

Jesus's message in Jerusalem prepared His disciples for the ministry and mission He would soon entrust to them. (This commentary will later say more about the connection between John 20:21-23 and the Great Commission and Jesus's post-resurrection time in Galilee).

Jesus focused His disciples on the life-mission He gave to them to accomplish without His physical presence on earth. Jesus would not be the One to take the Gospel to all nations. Jesus was sending His disciples to do that. As the Father has sent Me, I also send you (v 21).

For them to be able to accomplish their mission, Jesus had to prepare, empower, and authorize them to do the work He was sending them to do.

1. JESUS BLESSES THE DISCIPLES.

Before Jesus charged His disciples with the all-important task of proclaiming the Gospel, He blessed them a second time.

So Jesus said to them again, "Peace be with you…" (v 21a).

The pronoun them refers to those disciples who were present when Jesus appeared to them in Jerusalem. This included many of the remaining core disciples (Matthew 10:2-4). It did not include Judas, who had killed himself after regretting his betrayal of Jesus (Mattthew 27:3-5), nor Thomas who was not present (John 20:24). And it may not have included Peter, since Jesus had already appeared to Him (Luke 24:34, 1 Corinthians 15:5). In his parallel account, Luke also says others were there with them (Luke 24:33).

The word So connects Jesus's sudden appearance and the disciples' transformation from fear and doubt to rejoicing and belief at seeing the Lord suddenly standing alive in their midst (John 20:19-20) and the message He came to tell them (John 20:21-22.)

When Jesus first appeared to the disciples, He had greeted them: "Peace be with you" (John 20:19). They were so startled at seeing someone suddenly appear whom they imagined was dead, that His greeting of peace did not seem to register. They thought they were seeing a ghost (Luke 24:37).

So, now that they had finally recognized that Jesus was resurrected and was a real person who was really standing beside them, Jesus repeated His greeting again. Apparently, He did not want His disciples to overlook this blessing, so Jesus said to them again, "Peace be with you" (v 21).

The pronoun you specifically refers to the disciples Jesus appeared to and was addressing in this moment. More generally, you can refer to any follower of Jesus.

Once again, Jesus likely used the Hebrew greeting: "Shalom," when He said, "Peace be with you," as He also likely did in John 20:19.

As explained in The Bible Says commentary for John 20:19-20, the greeting "Peace be with you" is a translated meaning of the common Hebrew greeting: "Shalom."

Shalom expresses the idea of wholeness, well-being, harmony, completeness, and blessing. Shalom describes a state in which one's relationship with God and with others is rightly ordered and flourishing.

Throughout the Old Testament, shalom is repeatedly associated with God's covenant blessings upon His people (Numbers 6:24-26, Psalm 29:11, Isaiah 26:3).

In this moment, Jesus's greeting went beyond a customary salutation. Only days earlier His disciples had abandoned Him, Peter had denied Him three times, and they now hid behind locked doors in fear. Yet the risen Lord greeted them, not with words of rebuke or condemnation, but with "Peace be with you."

And it was through His recent death and resurrection that Jesus had just made "shalom" accessible. Peace between God and humanity that comes through the forgiveness of sins (Isaiah 53:5, Romans 5:1, Ephesians 2:14-18). This forgiveness was made available through the blood of Jesus's sacrifice (Colossians 1:13-14, 1:20).

So, in a real sense Jesus has brought "shalom" both to the disciples and to all who believe. And when He said, "Peace be with you," He was using an old expression of longing to express a new and joyful reality that His death and resurrection had accomplished re-harmonizing that which was broken. Through Jesus's sacrifice, now humans could be restored to fellowship with God and reconnected to their design.

Having reconciled them to God through His sacrifice, Jesus now assured His disciples that they stood before Him as forgiven friends, ready to receive the mission He was about to entrust to them.

It is significant that Jesus blessed His disciples with His peace before He charged them with their mission. Jesus's blessing is significant for at least three reasons.

First, and as mentioned above, Jesus assured His disciples that they stood before Him forgiven, accepted, and restored. Therefore, they would not have to carry out their mission from a place of uncertainty about where they stood with their Messiah. Having Jesus's blessing gave the disciples the knowledge and the confidence that Christ had reconciled them to Himself and counted them worthy to the divine task He was about to give them. This unconditional acceptance is given to all who believe in Jesus, having sufficient faith to look on Him in hope of being delivered from death (John 3:14-15).

Second, Jesus' blessing is notable because it parallels His commissioning. Just as the Father publicly affirmed His beloved Son before Jesus began His earthly ministry (Matthew 3:17), Jesus also blessed His disciples before entrusting them with theirs.

And third, the disciples would proclaim peace to the world because they had first received the peace of Christ themselves. They would go as men who had already experienced the grace, forgiveness, and reconciliation they were now being sent to announce to others.

John would later write how we love others because God first loves us (1 John 4:19). Christ's blessing of shalom and His call for them to bring news of the blessing of shalom to others shows how His disciples are redeemed (or in a sense, "shalomed") people who have a role to play in God's redemption ("shaloming") of the world. It is reasonable to affirm that Jesus's blessing fully flows through to all who believe in Him and are born of the Spirit as new creations in Him (John 3:3, 2 Corinthians 5:17).

After greeting His disciples with the blessing: "Peace be with you," Jesus then turned His disciples' attention from His resurrection to the important mission that lay before them.

2. JESUS PREPARES THE DISCIPLES FOR THEIR MISSION.

Before Jesus told His disciples what their mission was, He prepared them by giving them a pattern for how they were to accomplish it.

Jesus told His disciples: "as the Father has sent Me, I also send you" (v 21b).

A few nights earlier, just before He was arrested and killed, Jesus had prayed to His Father:

"As You sent Me into the world, I also have sent them into the world."
(John 17:18)

Jesus prayed this as He was about to complete His mission and He knew He would soon send His disciples into the world for their mission. Now, Jesus was informing His disciples of this plan, and He was preparing them by presenting His own mission as a model for them to follow.

In Philippians 2:5-10, Paul exhorts all believers to have the same mindset Jesus had. He was given a mission to sacrifice Himself for the sake of others. The "joy" set before Him was to be rewarded as a human the title of "Son" (Hebrews 1:5) and be given the authority humans had squandered at the Fall (Revelation 3:21, Matthew 28:18, Hebrews 2:9). As Hebrews 12:2 says, His "joy" was to be seated at His Father's right hand. In the Parable of the Talents, Jesus similarly asserts this reward to all who live as faithful witnesses and good stewards (Matthew 25:23).

But He was also doing more than just simply informing them. In saying "as the Father has sent Me, I also send you," Jesus was revealing to His disciples that their mission would mirror His mission in certain respects. Specifically, the manner in which the disciples' fulfilled their mission would reflect the manner in which Jesus fulfilled His.

The conjunction "as" is the key word in Jesus statement. It establishes the connection between the Father's sending of Jesus and Jesus’s sending of His disciples. They are to fulfill their mission as He has fulfilled His.

Jesus points to His own life as the pattern His disciples are to follow as they accomplish what He will send them to do. Jesus is directing His disciples to the pattern of trust, obedience, and dependence upon the Father and His reliance upon the Holy Spirit that He has faithfully modeled and lived before them during His three-year ministry.

The Father sent Jesus to do a mission. Likewise, Jesus would also send His disciples on a mission. The first mission established the pattern of the latter. The disciples would be able to look to Jesus to recall the way He carried out His mission as a model for them to emulate as they carried out their mission.

That mission is transmitted through to all believers. Jesus was sent as a sacrifice, believers in Him are exhorted to pursue their lives as a living sacrifice (Romans 12:1-2).

In saying "as the Father has sent Me, I also send you" (v 21), Jesus was revealing to His disciples that their mission would mirror His mission in certain respects. Specifically, the manner in which the disciples' fulfilled their mission was to reflect the manner in which Jesus fulfilled His.

Consider the following parallels between what the Father sent Jesus to do and what Jesus sends us to do.

Both Jesus and His disciples were Sent on a Life-Defining Mission.

Both Missions were Divinely Authorized.

Both Missions Received Their Objectives from the One Who Sent Them.

Both Missions were Fulfilled with the Aim of Pleasing the One Who Sent Them.

Both Missions were Accomplished in Divine Authority and the Power of the Holy Spirit.

Both Missions Required Unity.

Jesus was Sent to Accomplish Salvation, while His Disciples were Sent to Proclaim it.

Notice that the primary similarity between Jesus’s mission and the disciples' mission lies in the "how" and not the "what." Only one of the parallels listed above concerns what the mission was for. All the other parallels (except for the last one) are about how the mission was to be fulfilled.

We offer these parallels to demonstrate the pattern that Jesus intended His followers to recognize. As the Son lived in continual dependence upon His Father, so His disciples were to live in continual dependence upon Him. As Jesus sought His Father's will above His own, so His followers were to seek His will above their own. As Jesus acted in His Father's authority and by the power of the Holy Spirit, so His disciples were to carry out their mission in His authority and through the power of the Holy Spirit. The pattern of Jesus's life was to become the pattern of their lives.

Jesus had been preparing His disciples for this pattern throughout His final evening with them before His crucifixion.

  • He exhorted His disciples to exercise toward Him the same trust He continually demonstrated toward His Father.
    (John 14:1)

  • He assured them that they would continue His work because He was returning to the Father.
    (John 14:12-14)

  • He promised to send the Holy Spirit who would dwell within them as their Helper.
    (John 14:16-17, 26)

  • Jesus told them they were to abide in Him as the branches abide in the Vine (John 15:4-5). Just as Jesus accomplished nothing independently of His Father, neither could His disciples accomplish anything of lasting value apart from continual dependence upon Him.
    (John 15:4-5)

  • Jesus also warned His disciples that the world would hate them because it first hated Him.
    (John 15:18-20)

  • Yet they could take courage because He had overcome the world.
    (John 16:33)

  • Finally, in His prayer to the Father, Jesus declared: "As You sent Me into the world, I also have sent them into the world."
    (John 17:18)

The mission that Jesus was about to entrust to His disciples was therefore the natural continuation of the life He had already modeled before them.

This same pattern remains the pattern for every follower of Jesus. Christian discipleship is not merely believing the truths Jesus taught. It is learning to live as Jesus lived. Jesus called all who would be His disciple to deny themselves, take up their cross daily, and follow Him, explaining that whoever wishes to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for His sake will save it (Luke 9:23-24). A disciple's life is one of continual surrender, choosing Christ's will above personal ambition, comfort, and even self-preservation.

Jesus Himself perfectly embodied this way of life. He came "not to be served, but to serve, and to give His life a ransom for many" (Mark 10:45). On the night before His crucifixion He commanded His disciples, "love one another, even as I have loved you" (John 13:34), making His own sacrificial love the standard for theirs.

Paul later exhorted believers, "Have this attitude in yourselves which was also in Christ Jesus," describing how Jesus humbled Himself, took the form of a servant, and "became obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross" (Philippians 2:5-8). Likewise, the writer of Hebrews urges believers to run the race set before them by "fixing our eyes on Jesus," who endured the cross because of the joy set before Him (Hebrews 12:1-2).

The "joy" set before Jesus was to receive the reward of authority, being seated at His Father's right hand (Hebrews 12:2). Similarly, Jesus promises faithful believers that they will be rewarded for faithful stewardship by being made ruler over many things, and calls this "the joy of your master" in Matthew 25:21.

Jesus is, therefore, not only the Savior who accomplished our redemption. He is also the perfect example of faithful trust, humble obedience, sacrificial love, and steadfast endurance.

As the Father sent Him, so He now sends His followers to walk in the same pattern of life He first walked before them. This is why Jesus later exhorted the church of Ephesus to "overcome as I have overcome" (Revelation 3:21).

Before He gave His disciples their mission to make disciples of all nations (Matthew 28:19-20), Jesus first told them the way they were to accomplish this was by following His example. "As the Father has sent Me, I also send you." The mission of the Church is, therefore, not only to proclaim Christ, but to imitate Him, trusting God in every circumstance until He calls us home.

3. JESUS EMPOWERS THE DISCIPLES TO RECEIVE THE HOLY SPIRIT.

Jesus also empowered His disciples with the Holy Spirit to help them accomplish the divine task He was about to entrust to them. As promised, the disciples would not be left alone to do what God called them to do (John 14:18). God would be with them through the Holy Spirit who would help them accomplish their mission until the end of the age (Matthew 28:20, John 14:16),

And when He had said this, He breathed on them and said to them, "Receive the Holy Spirit" (v 22).

This passage is admittedly mysterious, as John does not explicitly explain everything that occurred when Jesus breathed upon His disciples. Nevertheless, when we consider the entire Bible—both the Old and New Testaments—we can get a clearer picture of what Jesus was doing when He breathed on them and said to them, “Receive the Holy Spirit.”

The expression And when He said this is the least mysterious part of the passage. This expression refers back to everything Jesus had just told His disciples in verse 21. He had pronounced Peace upon them, and declared, As the Father has sent Me, I also send you (v 21).

When He had finished saying those things (v 21), Jesus then breathed on His disciples and said: "Receive the Holy Spirit." This mysterious act both illustrated how His disciples were to accomplish their mission and equipped them to accomplish it.

Thus, Jesus's breathing on the disciples and saying to them: "Receive the Holy Spirit" was both a symbolic and a substantive action.

This commentary will discuss in detail both the symbolic nature, and the substantive reality of what Jesus did when He breathed on them and issued this command. But before we get into those details it would be good to first summarize the symbol and the substance.

As a Symbolic act, when Jesus breathed on the disciples to Receive the Holy Spirit He was:

  • Evoking the breath of life God breathed into Adam at Creation;
  • Depicting their sense of dependence upon Him as the Word of God
  • Evoking Ezekiel's vision of the valley of bones coming back to life;
  • Foreshadowing the indwelling of the Holy Spirit upon the disciples at Pentecost.

As Substantive act, when Jesus breathed on the disciples to Receive the Holy Spirit it was:

  • Distinct from the disciples' reception of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost
  • A temporary and/or partial reception in a manner consistent with the Old Testament.
  • An opening of their minds to understand the Scriptures and His teaching as Jesus prepared them for their mission before His ascension into heaven

Now that we have outlined what Jesus was doing with this symbolic and substantive act, this commentary will now more fully explain their meanings.

Jesus's Act of Breathing on His Disciples as a Symbolic Action

Jesus's breathing on His disciples when He issued the command "Receive the Holy Spirit" is full of symbolic meaning.

A. John's description of how Jesus breathed on the disciples echoes the creation account.

When God created the first man He breathed the spirit of life into him:

"The LORD God formed man of dust from the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living being."
(Genesis 2:7)

Adam's physical life began when God breathed into him.

Now the risen Christ likewise breathed upon His disciples. Just as God's breath brought natural life to the first creation, Jesus's breath symbolizes the spiritual life and power that would characterize the new creation inaugurated through His death and resurrection (2 Corinthians 5:17). The One through whom all things were created (John 1:3) now symbolically breathes His new covenant life into those He is sending to proclaim His Gospel.

B. John's description of how Jesus breathed on the disciples points to the disciples' total dependence on Christ to fulfill their life mission.

Jesus's breathing upon the disciples visibly portrayed that the life and power they would need for their mission would come from Him. Just as man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God (Deuteronomy 8:3), so too would His disciples find their spiritual lives sustained by Jesus, the Word of God (John 1:1), whose breath symbolized the life and power He would impart to them through the Holy Spirit.

Jesus is the firstborn of the dead (Colossians 1:18, Revelation 1:5). His resurrection and breath make our resurrection and breath possible. We live because He lives (John 14:19). His life grants and sustains our life.

C. John's description of how Jesus breathed on the disciples is reminiscent of Ezekiel's vision of the valley of dry bones, where God's breath entered lifeless bodies and the lived.

Ezekiel's prophecy (Ezekiel 37:1-14), pictured God's promise to restore His people by putting His Spirit within them. Jesus's act of breathing on His disciples when He first appeared to them after His resurrection signals that this promised restoration is about to begin.

D. John's description of how Jesus breathed on the disciples foreshadows the indwelling of the Holy Spirit upon the disciples at Pentecost.

When Jesus breathed on His disciples He said to them: "Receive the Holy Spirit" (v 22).

The Holy Spirit is God the Spirit. He is the third Person of the Trinity—fully God, eternal, personal, and equal with the Father and the Son. The Holy Spirit teaches, speaks, guides, comforts, convicts, intercedes, and empowers God's people. He possesses intellect, will, and emotion. The Holy Spirit is a divine Person.

Jesus's command, Receive the Holy Spirit, was not introducing a new subject to His disciples. Throughout His final evening with them before His crucifixion, Jesus repeatedly promised that after His departure He would send the Holy Spirit to dwell within them (John 14:16-17, 26, 15:26-27, 16:7, 13-14).

Three nights earlier, Jesus delivered much of this message about the Holy Spirit, likely in the same room the disciples were now in (This possible connection is explained below).

Jesus referred to the Holy Spirit as "the Helper" and "the Spirit of truth" whom the Father would send in His name (John 14:16-17, 26). The Holy Spirit would dwell with them and be in them, teaching them all things, bringing to their remembrance everything Jesus had taught them, and enabling them to faithfully bear witness concerning Him (John 15:26-27).

Jesus further explained that it was to their advantage that He go away, because only after His departure would He send the Helper to them (John 16:7). The coming of the Holy Spirit would therefore mark the beginning of a new phase in God’s redemptive plan, in which Christ would continue His work through His disciples by the indwelling presence and power of the Spirit.

Jesus also taught that the Holy Spirit would convict the world concerning sin, righteousness, and judgment (John 16:8-11), guide His disciples into all truth, disclose to them the things to come, and glorify Christ by taking what belonged to Jesus and revealing it to them (John 16:13-15).

Just as Jesus did not fulfill His mission in His own power but also the Holy Spirit's, so too would the disciples not fulfill their mission by their own wisdom, strength, or ability. They would accomplish it only because the Holy Spirit would empower them, illuminate the truth of Christ, and work through their witness to bring conviction and faith.

Jesus's command here in verse 22, Receive the Holy Spirit, therefore looked forward to the fulfillment of these promises.

The fulfillment came less than fifty days later on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:1-4).

As Jesus had instructed, His followers remained together in Jerusalem awaiting "the promise of the Father" (Acts 1:4-5). Then, "suddenly there came from heaven a noise like a violent rushing wind... And they were all filled with the Holy Spirit" (Acts 2:2-4).

The Holy Spirit came just as Jesus had promised, permanently indwelling His disciples and empowering them to proclaim the gospel to the nations. From that moment forward, the Church carried out its mission not by human strength but by the presence and power of God's Spirit.

While Jesus's act of breathing on His disciples as He bid them "Receive the Holy Spirit" was symbolic of creation, the disciples' complete dependence upon Christ, Ezekiel's vision, and the indwelling of the Holy Spirit that was soon to take place—it was also a substantive action that made a real change in the disciples.

Jesus's Act of Breathing on His Disciples as a Substantive Reality

Jesus brought about a transformative change within the disciples when He commanded them to receive the Holy Spirit. His act of breathing on His disciples and His command to "Receive the Holy Spirit" are linked together.

Jesus's command was not a bare imperative that only bid the disciples to receive something. It was an efficacious command that accomplished what it bid. It was akin to Jesus calming the storm when He said "Hush, be still" (Mark 4:39) or "Lazarus, come forth" (John 11:43). So also when Jesus breathed on them and issued the command, He caused them to receive the Holy Spirit. In this moment, the disciples really did receive the Holy Spirit, but not in the same way that they would receive the Holy Spirit fifty days later at Pentecost.

A. There was a difference between the disciples' receiving of the Holy Spirit here in John 20:22 and their receiving of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost in Acts 2.

Even though the Messiah had come, been crucified, and resurrected back to life, the Age of the Holy Spirit had not yet arrived. The Messiah was still on earth and would be for another forty days. The Age of the Holy Spirit would begin at Pentecost.

The Age of the Holy Spirit is the present era of God's redemptive plan that began after Jesus's (the Messiah) death, resurrection, ascension, and the outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost. During this age, the Holy Spirit indwells, empowers, sanctifies, and equips all who believe in Jesus, enabling the Church to proclaim the Gospel and make disciples until Christ returns.

Before He was crucified, Jesus told His disciples that in order for the Holy Spirit to come to them, that He would have to first leave. Jesus said:

"For if I do not go away, the Helper will not come to you; but if I go, I will send Him to you."
(John 16:7b)

Therefore, when Jesus breathed on them and said: "Receive the Holy Spirit," the Holy Spirit did not come to the disciples to the extent that the Holy Spirit did when He came at Pentecost. The Holy Spirit could not fully come yet because Jesus had not yet left earth for heaven and the Age of the Holy Spirit had not yet arrived.

Perhaps one of the reasons for the dramatic scene when the disciples later received the Holy Spirit at Pentecost was to help them clearly distinguish between this temporary and limited impartation of the Holy Spirit and the complete impartation that was soon to come upon them. When the Holy Spirit came fully and permanently upon them at Pentecost, the disciples:

  • Heard a noise like a violent rushing wind from heaven
    (Acts 2:2)

  • Saw flaming tongues of fire resting over one another’s heads
    (Acts 2:3)

  • Had a sudden ability to speak in other languages
    (Acts 2:4)

Nothing like these things is described here in John when Jesus breathed on them. Those signs may have been given to help the disciples recognize that Pentecost was the moment they fully received the Holy Spirit and/or that the new era (the Age of the Holy Spirit) had arrived.

B. Jesus seems to have imparted the Holy Spirit to His disciples in a manner similar to how God's Spirit was given in the Old Testament times.

Again, Jesus was still in the old era when He breathed on His disciples and said: "Receive the Holy Spirit" on the day of His resurrection.

Moreover, the disciples' reception of the Holy Spirit at this time appears to have been temporary and limited rather than permanent and complete. Their reception of the Holy Spirit when Jesus first appeared to them resembled the pattern frequently seen throughout the Old Testament, where the Spirit of God temporarily came upon particular individuals to equip them for a specific calling or season of service.

Throughout the Old Testament, God's Spirit came upon His servants to equip them for particular responsibilities:

  • The Spirit rested upon the seventy elders to help them bear the burden of leading Israel alongside Moses (Numbers 11:16-17, 24-30).
  • The Spirit rushed upon Samson and empowered him to accomplish extraordinary acts of strength (Judges 14:6, 19, 15:14).
  • After Saul was anointed king, the Spirit of God came upon him so that he prophesied (1 Samuel 10:6, 10), though the Spirit later departed from him because of his rebellion (1 Samuel 16:14).
  • Likewise, after Samuel anointed David, "the Spirit of the LORD came mightily upon David from that day forward" (1 Samuel 16:13).

Jesus's impartation of the Holy Spirit to His disciples in verse 22 bears a similar trait to those Old Testament impartations because their reception of the Holy Spirit seems to have been temporarily or partially given for a specific task. It was only at Pentecost, (after Jesus had ascended into heaven) that the Holy Spirit would permanently indwell believers, unite them into one body, and empower the Church to proclaim the Gospel to the nations (John 14:16, Acts 2:1-4, Romans 8:9, 1 Corinthians 12:13, Ephesians 1:13-14). John 20:22 therefore better fits the Old Covenant pattern of the reception of God's Spirit for a specific task rather than the New Covenant ministry of the indwelling Holy Spirit that was soon to come.

C. Jesus equipped the disciples for their immediate task while they awaited the fuller reception of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost.

The immediate task at hand was for the disciples to understand the major shift that was about to take place in the implementation of God's kingdom on earth. Jesus had just fulfilled the Law and defeated sin and death, but the king (Jesus) was about to return to His Father in heaven. The disciples only moments before were hiding in fear, but they were soon to be sent to boldly proclaim the life-saving Gospel to a world that would hate them. Their mentality needed to rapidly shift from travelling the countryside of Judea following Jesus to being sent out to make disciples without Him by their side. 

Jesus had explained this plan to them in the Upper Room after celebrating the Passover (John 14) and on their way to the Garden of Gethsemane (John 15-17), but they did not seem able to comprehend it. Throughout His ministry, Jesus had also plainly foretold to the disciples of His death and resurrection numerous times (Matthew 12:39-40, 16:21, 17:22-23, 20:17-19, 26:2, John 2:19-22, 12:23-24, 32-33, 13:31-33, 16:16-22), but they did not understand it.

John reveals that the disciples also did not understand what Jesus meant when He said, "Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up" (John 2:19) until after "He was raised from the dead" (John 2:22).

And when He washed His disciples' feet, Jesus assured them that, "What I do you do not realize now, but you will understand hereafter" (John 13:7). And Jesus later said:

"I have many more things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now. But when He, the Spirit of truth, comes, He will guide you into all the truth."
(John 16:12-13)

Perhaps Luke gives the most blunt explanation of why the disciples did not understand these things:

"They did not understand this statement, and it was concealed from them so that they would not perceive it."
(Luke 9:45)

All of these Scriptures indicate that the disciples were largely incapable of understanding many important things that Jesus said until the appropriate time. Now that Jesus had been raised from the dead and would soon leave, it was the appropriate time for them to gain this understanding. And Jesus's breathing on the disciples and bidding them "Receive the Holy Spirit" was done to help open their eyes to the things God had done, and to things Jesus would teach them over the coming weeks before He ascended into heaven.

Just before Jesus appeared to the group of disciples in Jerusalem (Luke 24:36-43, John 20:19-23), as He walked on the road (unrecognized) with two of His disciples, He said to them:

"O foolish men and slow of heart to believe in all that the prophets have spoken! Was it not necessary for the Christ to suffer these things and to enter into His glory?"
(Luke 24:25-26)

Luke continues:

"Then beginning with Moses and with all the prophets, He explained to them the things concerning Himself in all the Scriptures."
(Luke 24:27)

Before Jesus left that pair of disciples, "their eyes were opened and they recognized Him" (Luke 24:31). And the two disciples said: "Were not our hearts burning within us while He was speaking to us on the road, while He was explaining the Scriptures to us?" (Luke 24:32).

Something like the opening of these disciples' eyes to the Scriptures may have happened when Jesus breathed on the group of disciples and said: "Receive the Holy Spirit."

Having their minds open to why Jesus died and raised to life, and the things He had taught and was about to teach them would prepare them to better partner with God and embrace the mission Jesus was about to assign them.

The disciples stood at the threshold of a unique calling. Over the next forty days they were going to be trained and prepared for their life-mission to carry the Gospel into the world. To help them better understand their training, Jesus imparted the Holy Spirit to them in a preparatory manner, equipping them for the unique period between His resurrection and ascension during which He would continue teaching them about the kingdom of God (Acts 1:3).

There are a few more things to mention and briefly explain before we move onto Jesus's authorization of the disciples to share the Gospel.

It is quite possible that the Holy Spirit descended upon the disciples in the very same upper room where Jesus celebrated the Passover with them and told them about the Holy Spirit, and where Jesus now first appeared to them after His resurrection and breathed on them saying: Receive the Holy Spirit.

If this was indeed the same upper room where Jesus celebrated the Passover with His disciples, then it was already a place of profound significance. It was there that Jesus instituted the Lord's Supper, washed His disciples' feet, delivered His Farewell Discourse (John 13-17), promised the coming of the Holy Spirit, and prayed His great High Priestly Prayer before going out to Gethsemane. It would therefore be fitting that the room in which Jesus first revealed the blessings of the New Covenant also became the place where those blessings began to be realized through His resurrection appearances and, ultimately, through the coming of the Holy Spirit.

Mark and Luke record that Jesus instructed two of His disciples to prepare the Passover in "a large furnished upper room" (Mark 14:15; Luke 22:12). Luke records that after Jesus's ascension the apostles "went up to the upper room where they were staying" (Acts 1:13), and he later notes that on the day of Pentecost "they were all together in one place" (Acts 2:1).

While Scripture does not explicitly identify this location as the same room, the continuity of the narrative makes it a reasonable possibility. If so, the room that first witnessed the risen Christ's symbolic act of breathing on His disciples also became the place where His promise was first explained and also gloriously fulfilled.

It is also fitting that all three Persons of the Godhead appear together in Jesus's preparation of His disciples. All three Persons of Godhead were recorded as present at Jesus's baptism: the Father spoke, Jesus was baptized, and the Holy Spirit descended in the form of a dove when He first began His Messianic ministry (Matthew 3:16-17, Mark 1:9-11, Luke 3:21-22). And all three Persons of the Godhead are mentioned in the Great Commission of Matthew 28:18-20. This is another way that Jesus sends His followers out just as the Father sent Him.

The Father sent the Son into the world. The Son now sends His disciples. And the Holy Spirit will empower them to carry out the mission they have received.

4. JESUS AUTHORIZES THE DISCIPLES TO SHARE THE GOSPEL.

After Jesus blessed His disciples with His "shalom" (peace), and prepared them for their mission by giving them His own life as model for them to follow, and had empowered them to receive the Holy Spirit, He then authorized them to share the Gospel.

"If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them; if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained" (v 23).

In this statement, Jesus was placing the Gospel that He had accomplished with His death and resurrection into the hands of His disciples. Jesus would not physically be present on earth for much longer. They would be the ones to communicate who Jesus was, what He did, and what He offers to those who believed in Him. Jesus was entrusting them with "the keys of the kingdom" (Matthew 16:19), as He first told Peter and then later the other disciples:

"Truly I say to you, whatever you bind on earth shall have been bound in heaven; and whatever you loose on earth shall have been loosed in heaven."
(Matthew 18:18—See also Matthew 16:19)

Jesus had told Peter and the disciples these things while He was still among them, and what He told them then (in Matthew 16:19, 18:18) foreshadowed a time when they would have greater authority. That time was about to come, when Jesus would return to His Father in heaven and command His disciples to "Go into all the world and preach the gospel to all creation" (Mark 16:15).

The Gospel they were to preach included both the Gift and the Prize of Eternal Life. At the heart of the Gift of Eternal Life lies the forgiveness of sins.

In this charge, Jesus seems uses the idea of the forgiveness of sins as a shorthand expression for the Gospel as a whole. This conditional statement implements a synecdoche—which is an expression that uses a part to represent the whole.

In stating the forgiveness of sins, Jesus draws upon the very heart of the Gospel He was authorizing His disciples to proclaim.

Moreover, Jesus was endorsing and/or authorizing His apostles' future proclamation of the Gospel as the definitive testimony concerning who He is and the eternal life He offers.

This meant that when false teachers later arose and began to distort or proclaim a different gospel, the apostles' testimony would serve as the authoritative standard by which every competing message was to be judged. Paul warned the Galatians that even if an angel from heaven preached a gospel contrary to the one the apostles had proclaimed, that message was to be rejected (Galatians 1:6-9).

Likewise, Jude urged believers to "contend earnestly for the faith which was once for all handed down to the saints" (Jude 1:3), and Peter warned of false teachers who would secretly introduce destructive heresies (2 Peter 2:1-3). John wrote 1 John in large part to expose and combat the false teachings about Jesus so that all believers could experience the full blessings of eternal life.

The apostles faithfully fulfilled this trust by proclaiming the Gospel throughout the world and preserving their eyewitness testimony in the writings that became the New Testament (2 Peter 1:16-21, 1 John 1:1-4). Through their apostolic witness, the definitive testimony and truths of the Gospel have been preserved in the Bible. The Bible faithfully tells us who Jesus is, what He accomplished through His death and resurrection, and proclaims the eternal life He freely offers to all who believe in Him (John 3:14-15, Revelation 21:6).

Because Jesus was speaking about the Gospel as a whole when He told His disciples If you forgive the sins of any, their sins have been forgiven them; and if you retain the sins of any, they have been retained (v 23), He was not granting them autonomous authority to decide who and who is not forgiven and/or who does or does not get into heaven. He was instead telling them that they would be responsible for sharing the truth about who Jesus was and for accurately proclaiming (and defending) the Gospel.

This understanding is also consistent with the pattern established in the Old Testament. Under the Law, priests did not possess the authority to cleanse a leper; they carefully examined the person and officially declared clean what God had already healed (Leviticus 13-14). Likewise, the prophet Nathan did not personally forgive David's sin after his repentance; he announced God's verdict: "The LORD also has taken away your sin" (2 Samuel 12:13).

In the same way, Jesus was not authorizing His disciples to determine who was or was not forgiven, but to faithfully proclaim God's verdict concerning forgiveness through the Gospel. Their authority was declarative rather than determinative. They announced the forgiveness God grants to those who believe in Jesus, and they declared that those who reject Him remain in their sins (John 3:18, 36).

Just as the Father did not send Jesus into the world to condemn people of their sins, but to provide a way for them to be saved from their sins (John 3:17) so also does Jesus not send His disciples into the world to pronounce who is or is not forgiven of their sins, but only to proclaim, "repentance for forgiveness of sins" (Luke 24:47).

Having considered the overall meaning of Jesus's conditional statement of verse 23, we are now prepared to examine His wording more closely. The construction of Jesus's sentence and the meaning of its key words confirm and illuminate the authority He was entrusting to His disciples.

Jesus's statement is concise, but every part of it contributes to its meaning. To understand what Jesus was authorizing His disciples to do, it is helpful to consider three features of His statement:

  • its grammatical structure,
  • its principal subjects,
  • and the meaning of its key verbs.

Jesus's teaching in verse 23 consists of a conditional sentence composed of two parallel clauses.

The first clause states: if you forgive the sins of any…

It is followed by the result: their sins have been forgiven them.

The second clause mirrors the first: if you retain the sins of any.

And it is followed by its corresponding result: they have been retained.

The principle subjects of Jesus's statement are the pronouns: you, any, them, their, and they.

The personal pronoun you refers to Jesus's disciples. You specifically refers to the group of disciples Jesus was addressing when He appeared to them in Jerusalem.

The relative pronoun any refers to literally anyone. In this context any is not exclusive to a particular group of people such as the Jewish people or Roman people, but anyone, Jew or Gentile. Neither is any confined to a finite number of people. Any includes an unlimited number of people.

The Gospel was to be preached to "all the nations" (Matthew 28:19, Luke 24:47), "in all the world" (Mark 16:15), "even to the remotest part of the earth" (Acts 1:8).

The pronouns their and them each refers to the inclusive, worldwide any.

And the pronoun they refer the sins of any that the disciples forgive or retain.

Both conditional clauses deal with the two ways that Jesus's disciples deal with the sins of anyone. The two ways Jesus describes are to forgive the sins of any and to retain them.

The forgiveness and retention of sins stand at the center of Jesus's statement because the forgiveness of sins stands at the heart of the Gospel. Understanding what Jesus means therefore begins with understanding the biblical problem of sin and God's provision for its forgiveness.

Sins are acts of disobedience against God and failures to live according to His design, His holy character, and righteous standards (Romans 3:23, 1 John 3:4). Every person has sinned, and sin separates humanity from God, bringing spiritual death. Death is separation, and separation from God places all people under His righteous judgment (Isaiah 59:2, Romans 3:23, 6:23, James 1:15). Left unforgiven, sin alienates people from fellowship with God and leaves them unable to reconcile themselves to Him (Matthew 6:14-15, Ephesians 2:1-3, Colossians 1:21).

Through His death on the cross, Jesus bore the penalty for the sins of the world, satisfying God's justice and making forgiveness available to all who believe in Him (Isaiah 53:5-6, John 1:29, 1 Peter 2:24). By His resurrection, Jesus triumphed over sin and death, securing eternal life for all who trust in Him and commissioning His disciples to proclaim this message of forgiveness to the world (John 20:21-23, Matthew 28:18-20, Mark 16;:15, Acts 1:8, Romans 4:25, 1 Corinthians 15:20-22, Colossians 2:13-15).

The verbs of these conditional clauses—forgive or retain—are used as opposites. They are contrasting actions.

The Greek term that is translated as forgive is a form of ἀφίημι (G863—pronounced: af-ē-ay-mē). "Afēaymē" literally means "to send away," "release," "let go," "dismiss," or "remit." When used of sins, "afēaymē" describes the act of removing guilt or releasing a person from the debt and penalty of sin so that it no longer stands against them (Matthew 9:2, Luke 7:47-48, Acts 10:43).

The Greek term that is translated as retain is a form of κρατέω (G2902—pronounced: kra-teh-ō). "Kratehō" literally means "to seize," "take hold of," "grasp firmly," "hold fast," "keep," or "retain." When used of sins, kratehō describes the act of holding sins fast or leaving them in place, rather than releasing or removing them, making it the deliberate opposite of "afēaymē."

Moreover, the Greek tense and voice of the verbs have been forgiven and have been retained in Jesus's authorization confirms that God—not the disciples—is the One who forgives or retains sins.

The verbs translated have been forgiven and have been retained are both in the perfect passive tense. Their perfect aspect describes a completed action whose results continue into the present.  Their passive voice indicates that the action is performed upon the sinner rather than by the sinner, or, in this context, by the disciples. In other words, the forgiveness or retention of sins is presented as something God has already accomplished or determined. The disciples' role is not to create that verdict, but to declare it faithfully through their proclamation of the Gospel.

The grammatical structure and wording of Jesus's conditional statement therefore reinforce its overall meaning. Jesus was not granting His disciples autonomous authority to forgive or retain sins. He was authorizing them to proclaim the Gospel, at the heart of which lies the forgiveness of sins.

Luke records this same commission in even more explicit terms when Jesus declared:

"Repentance for forgiveness of sins would be proclaimed in His name to all the nations, beginning from Jerusalem. You are witnesses of these things."
(Luke 24:47-48)

Jesus entrusted disciples with bearing authoritative witness to Christ and announcing the forgiveness of sins that His death and resurrection had accomplished.

John does not record anything else that Jesus said to the disciples at this time when they were in Jerusalem. The next time John describes one of Jesus's post-resurrection appearances is "eight days later" (John 20:26).

But first John tells us about the disciple Thomas, who was not present for this appearance recorded here in verses 21-23, and how he did not believe his fellow disciples that Jesus was raised from the dead (John 20:24-25).

A word about Jesus's command to see Him in Galilee

On the night of His arrest, Jesus told His disciples that they would soon abandon Him, but that after He was raised back to life, they were to leave Jerusalem and meet Him in Galilee (Matthew 26:31-32). In that moment, the disciples only seemed to focus on and dispute what Jesus said about their abandoning Him and ignored what Jesus said about resurrection and His instruction to see Him in Galilee (Matthew 26:33-35).

Jesus instructed His disciples to go to Galilee because He had important things to teach them in the roughly forty-day window between His resurrection and ascension. He was about to leave earth. And Jesus's followers would be the ones who implemented God's will to redeem the world. Jesus needed to prepare and equip them for this most important mission.

Jesus may have thought that it would be easier to accomplish this task away from the crowds and watchful eyes in Jerusalem. If the authorities and or multitudes saw Jesus alive after His crucifixion, it would be challenging to have focused, quiet moments with His disciples. So, Jesus may have thought the hills of Galilee would be a better place for Him to share the important things He needed to share with His disciples before He left earth.

When the group of women encountered the angels in the tomb, the angel informed the women that Jesus was alive and that He commanded the women to remind the disciples to go to Galilee as Jesus had instructed them to do after His resurrection (Matthew 28:7, Mark 16:7). And when Jesus later appeared to these women, He repeated this command (Matthew 28:10).

The women obeyed the angels and Jesus, and informed the disciples of Jesus's resurrection, while also reminding them of His instruction for them to meet Him in Galilee, but the disciples did not believe (Mark 16:11) or immediately act on this instruction. Instead, late in the day of Jesus's resurrection, they were afraid and hiding from the Jews behind closed doors (John 20:19-20) in Jerusalem (Luke 24:33).

It was not until Jesus suddenly appeared in their midst on the evening of His resurrection that the disciples became convinced He was truly alive (John 20:19-20, Luke 24:36-43). Even then, they did not appear to leave for Galilee immediately. John's account indicates that Thomas was absent from this first appearance, and that Jesus appeared to the disciples again "after eight days," while they were still gathered together in the same house (John 20:24-29).

This suggests that the disciples remained in Jerusalem for at least another week before eventually traveling north to Galilee in obedience to Jesus's repeated instruction.

The journey to Galilee would be the setting for several of Jesus's final appearances and some of His most important post-resurrection teaching, before He traveled back to Jerusalem to ascend to heaven from the Mount of Olives. It was in Galilee He restored Peter after his denial (John 21:15-19) and likely gave His disciples the Great Commission to make disciples of all the nations (Matthew 28:18-20).

For a listing of what happened after this moment and Jesus's ascension into heaven, see The Bible Says article: "What Happened Between Jesus's Resurrection and His Ascension? Part 2."