John 20:24-25 meaning
There are no apparent parallels of John 20:24-25 in the Bible.
In John 20:24-25, Thomas rejects the other disciples' testimony that Jesus has risen from the dead and insists upon personally seeing and touching Jesus's wounds before he will believe.
In the previous two sections (John 20:19-20, 20:21-23) John described Jesus's first appearance to His disciples on the afternoon of His resurrection while they were gathered behind locked doors in Jerusalem for fear of the Jews. After proving that He had truly risen from the dead by showing them His hands and His side, Jesus blessed them with His peace, prepared them for the mission He would soon entrust to them, breathed on them as a sign of the Holy Spirit they would soon receive, and authorized them to proclaim the Gospel of the forgiveness of sins.
Several of the eleven disciples, along with unnamed others (Luke 24:33), were present when Jesus appeared, but at least one of them was not there.
But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came (v 24).
John uses the conjunction But to transition from what he wrote about Jesus's appearance and message (John 20:19-23) to what he is about to write about Thomas.
John identifies Thomas as one Jesus's core disciples and explains the meaning of Thomas's name to his Greek readers.
Thomas was one of the twelve core disciples whom Jesus called (Matthew 10:2-4). For approximately three years, Thomas traveled with Jesus, heard His teaching firsthand, witnessed His miracles, and observed His sinless life.
John's Gospel includes two comments that Thomas made earlier in Jesus's ministry that the other Gospels do not.
Late in His ministry, Jesus told the disciples that they were going to visit his friend Lazarus who was sick (John 11:1). This decision was unpopular among the disciples, because Bethany was near Jerusalem where Jesus's powerful enemies were (John 11:1-15). The disciples seemed to fear for Jesus's life if they went to Bethany at this time. But Jesus was determined to go. Then Thomas said to the other disciples:
"Let us also go, so that we may die with Him."
(John 11:16)
Thomas's remark may indicate that he was a pessimist. Thomas may have preferred to prepare for unpleasant possibilities to guard himself from the pain of being disappointed when positive outcomes did not happen. If so, that temperament might explain why Thomas later refused to believe the reports of Jesus's resurrection until he had seen the risen Lord for himself.
It is also worth noting that prior to this statement, all the disciples agreed together that going south was dangerous, as John 11:8 says, "The disciples said to Him, 'Rabbi, the Jews were just now seeking to stone You, and are You going there again?'" It was not mere speculation, but a known reality that the Jewish leaders wanted to kill Jesus. So, we can also view Thomas's statement as reflecting the mentality of a zealot.
The zealot headquarters were a few miles from Capernaum, and zealot sentiment was common in northern Galilee. Zealots were willing to die for the cause, which is likely why most of Jesus's disciples ended up coming from this area—Jesus was looking for disciples that would give up all to follow Him. Jesus recruited zealots willing to die, then worked to reorient their attitude from commitment to their own agenda to commit to God's agenda.
One way to view this interaction between Jesus and Thomas is that John was recording this as a picture of the conversion all the disciples made from being a "my way" zealot to a "God's way" zealot. God's way was to serve others sacrificially. Jesus kept telling them He was going to make the ultimate sacrifice of Himself, and they did not have ears to hear.
Thomas was with Jesus and the other members of the twelve in the upper room when Jesus washed the disciples' feet and celebrated the Passover together (John 13:1-20), and when Jesus began to explain the things that were about to take place (His betrayal, crucifixion, resurrection, ascension, the coming of the Holy Spirit) (John 13:21 - 14:31). In that discourse, Jesus said to them: "And you know the way where I am going" (John 14:4).
Thomas bluntly interjected:
"Lord, we do not know where You are going, how do we know the way?"
(John 14:5)
Jesus answered Thomas's question:
"I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me."
(John 14:6)
Thomas's interjection may indicate that he possessed a concrete disposition and desired a thorough or solid understanding before accepting a claim. He appears to have been a man who was willing to ask difficult questions rather than settle for incomplete answers. Again, if true, this disposition aligns with Thomas's later insistence on seeing the risen Jesus before choosing to believe that Jesus was alive.
John may have specifically mentioned that Thomas was the disciple who said these things in those earlier passages (John 11:16, 14:5 ) as a way to prepare his readers for Thomas's doubt in this passage.
John writes that Thomas was called Didymus.
Didymus is the Greek word for "twin": Δίδυμος (G1324—Di-dy-mos). In Hebrew, the name Thomas is תְּאוֹמָא (H8382—pronounced: "Te-oma"). The name itself is derived from the Aramaic and Hebrew words for twin: תְּאוֹם (H8380), which likewise means twin. John therefore records both Thomas's Hebrew/Aramaic name and its Greek equivalent for the benefit of his readers.
While Scripture never identifies Thomas's twin or even states explicitly that he had one, his name strongly suggests that he was a twin. It is possible that the name Thomas functioned as a descriptive nickname for this disciple, and that John is pointing this out when he writes that Thomas means "twin." If Thomas was this disciple's nickname, we do not know his given name.
After introducing Thomas as one of the twelve core disciples, who was called Didymus, John mentions the fact that Thomas did not see Jesus when He first appeared to the disciples as they were hiding in Jerusalem.
The reason Thomas did not see Jesus then was because he was not with them when Jesus came (v 24).
John continues by revealing that the disciples told Thomas that Jesus was alive and how they had seen Him with their own eyes.
So the other disciples were saying to him, "We have seen the Lord!" (v 25a).
The expression So connects what the other disciples told Thomas with the fact that he had not been with them when Jesus came (v 24). Because Thomas missed Jesus's appearance, the other disciples began telling him what they had personally witnessed.
The other disciples were saying to him, "We have seen the Lord!" (v 25).
The expression were saying in Greek is in the imperfect tense which describes a past action or series of actions in a continuous aspect. The use of the imperfect tense suggests that the disciples repeatedly told Thomas about this good news.
The pronoun we refers to the disciples who were present when Jesus appeared to them. The Lord was Jesus. Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God. Jesus is the Lord.
The disciples' declaration "We have seen the Lord!" was their collective eyewitness testimony that Jesus was alive. They were telling their fellow disciples that what the women had said about Jesus was true. Their Lord was alive. They knew Jesus was alive because they had seen Jesus also.
Their testimony was based on what they themselves had seen with their own eyes when Jesus suddenly stood in their midst, spoke to them, and let them touch His hands and His side (John 20:19-20—See also Luke 24:36-42).
Multiple people, including Mary Magdalene (Mark 16:9, John 20:11-18), the other women (Matthew 28:8-10), Cleopas and the other disciple (Luke 24:13-35), Peter (Luke 24:34, 1 Corinthians 15:5), and a group of the core disciples (Luke 24:36-43, John 20:19-23) were now all independently affirming the same extraordinary claim: the Lord whom they had seen crucified and buried was now alive—and they had personally seen Him.
John then reveals Thomas's response to his fellow disciples' report.
But he said to them, "Unless I see in His hands the imprint of the nails, and put my finger into the place of the nails, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe" (v 25b).
Thomas doubted the disciples' claim that they had seen the Lord. It seems as though Thomas was so adamant in his doubt that nothing they said could convince him that they really had seen Jesus and/or that He had risen from the dead.
Thomas said that he would not believe that Jesus was alive unless he experienced three things:
- I see in His hands the imprint of the nails,
- and put my finger into the place of the nails,
- and put my hand into His side.
The first thing Thomas demanded was to see in His hands the imprint of the nails (v 25).
The imprint of the nails refers to the visible wounds and holes left by the spikes that had pierced Jesus's hands during His crucifixion (John 19:17-18). Thomas wanted to see in them, which may have meant that Thomas wanted see through the holes that the nails had left in Jesus's hands.
These scars would have identified the risen Jesus as the same person who had been nailed to the cross only days before. Thomas was not looking for someone who merely resembled Jesus or who claimed to be Him but was not. Thomas wanted indubitable and unrepeatable evidence that whoever he saw really was the crucified Jesus who had risen from the dead. Anyone who had recently been crucified, like Jesus had, would have holes in their hands from the nails, and it was highly unlikely that anyone who had not been crucified would have holes in their hands.
Thomas's insistence that he would not believe unless he saw the nails in His hands, etc. may have indicated that he suspected that the disciples had seen someone who deceptively claimed to be Jesus. Remember, Mary Magdalene (John 20:11-14) and the two disciples on the road to Emmaus had not immediately recognized Jesus (Luke 24:13-31), which could have fueled Thomas's suspicions that the person they saw was not really Jesus.
The second thing Thomas demanded was to put my finger into the place of the nails (v 25).
This requirement went beyond merely seeing the wounds. Thomas insisted that he put his finger into the place of the nails (v 25), personally touching the scars left by the crucifixion. This demand demonstrates that Thomas desired more than visual confirmation; he wanted tangible, examinable evidence that Jesus's resurrection was physical and bodily.
Thomas's request may have indicated that he suspected that the disciples saw a spirit or vision and not a physical flesh and blood person. It was strange how Jesus had vanished from the sight of Cleopas and the other disciple (Luke 24:31), and how Jesus appeared suddenly standing in the midst of the other disciples when they were inside with the doors shut and locked (John 20:19).
Sudden vanishing and materializing are not things that physical bodies normally do. The vanishing and appearing that the disciples reported was more associated with immaterial beings. If the disciples only saw Jesus's spirit, then He had not physically been raised from the dead. But by touching the scars in Jesus's hands with his finger, Thomas could verify that the person he was touching was no phantom, but a physical person.
The third thing Thomas demanded was to put my hand into His side.
When Thomas declared that he must put his hand into Jesus’s side he was referring to the wound inflicted by the Roman soldier’s spear after Jesus had already died upon the cross (John 19:33-37). John had earlier emphasized that this piercing fulfilled Scripture and confirmed beyond question that Jesus was truly dead before He was taken down from the cross.
Thomas's third requirement therefore concerned more than identifying Jesus. It concerned verifying that the person he saw was the same crucified Savior whose death had been publicly confirmed. By demanding to touch the wound in Jesus's side, Thomas sought undeniable evidence that Jesus had not merely survived the crucifixion, but had died, been buried, and then bodily risen from the dead.
Examining the scar in Jesus's side would have not only confirmed that the person Thomas saw was Jesus, but also that this person had really died and had come back to life.
Thomas said he will not believe that Jesus has been raised from the dead unless he could personally do all three of these things.
There are two more aspects of Thomas’s doubt that may be beneficial to consider before we move onto the next section commentary, explaining Jesus’s appearance to Thomas and Thomas's change of mind (John 20:26-29).
Thomas's Doubt Supports the Authenticity of the Gospels
The first aspect is how the negative depiction of Thomas is part of the pattern of the negative depiction of the disciples throughout the Gospels and how their negative depiction adds credibility to the Gospel accounts.
Rather than portraying themselves as fearless heroes or men of exceptional faith, the disciples are repeatedly depicted as foolish, selfish, hard-headed sinners. Throughout the Gospels, the disciples misunderstand Jesus's teaching (Mark 8:31-33), argue among themselves about who is the greatest (Luke 22:24), flee when Jesus is arrested (Matthew 26:56), Peter publicly denies knowing Him three times (Matthew 26:69-75), and even after hearing multiple reports of Jesus's resurrection, they struggle to believe that He is alive (Mark 16:11-14, Luke 24:11, 36-43). Thomas's refusal to believe the testimony of his fellow disciples is another example of the Gospel writers candidly recording the failures, weaknesses, and doubts of Jesus's closest followers.
This repeated pattern of self-incriminating honesty adds credibility to the Gospel accounts. Had the disciples invented these narratives in an attempt to establish their own authority, it is unlikely they would have consistently portrayed themselves as fearful, confused, unbelieving, and slow to understand the very truths they later proclaimed. If they were making this up, they would have been far more likely to present themselves in a good light.
Their willingness to preserve these embarrassing details, even when they reflected poorly upon themselves, bears the marks of truthful eyewitness testimony rather than carefully crafted propaganda. Thomas's doubt therefore does not undermine the credibility of the resurrection accounts. The record of his doubts strengthens them by demonstrating the honesty with which the evangelists recorded what actually happened.
Also, by presenting the disciples as screw-ups, the Gospels demonstrate that the invitation of Jesus is truly available to all who are willing to follow Him and not only those who view themselves as wise or morally pre-qualified.
Thomas's Demands for Proof Support the Truth of Jesus's Resurrection
The other aspect is that Thomas's doubts and demands serve as proofs for Jesus's resurrection from the dead.
Thomas's doubts and demands represent the very questions many people have asked throughout history concerning Jesus's resurrection. And they are a kind of stand-in for the doubts and demand of proof for John's readers. We cannot go back in time and do what Thomas did, but in a sense, he can doubt and examine for us.
Thomas's doubts and demands to see the imprint of the nails in Jesus's hands, to put his finger in the holes left by the nails, and to put his hand in His side where the spear had stabbed His dead body are a surrogate for our doubts and demand of tangible evidence that Jesus actually rose from the dead and that the disciples were not fools to believe that Jesus was resurrected.
- By seeing the imprint of the nails in Jesus's hands, Thomas could verify that the risen Lord was the very same Jesus who had been crucified only days before.
- By putting his finger into the holes left by the nails, Thomas could verify that Jesus's resurrection was physical and bodily, not merely a vision, ghost, or spiritual appearance.
- And by putting his hand into Jesus's side where the Roman spear had pierced Him, Thomas could verify that Jesus had truly died before being buried and therefore had genuinely risen from the dead rather than merely survived the crucifixion.
The New Testament presents the resurrection of Jesus as the historical proof for its claims. If the resurrection is false, then faith falls apart (1 Corinthians 15:13-19). But if the resurrection is true, then all that it claims about Jesus, God, righteousness, the afterlife, are also true and should be believed and embraced. No other faith rests on a historical claim the way that Christianity rests on the historical claim of the resurrection.
Thomas's skepticism invites readers to examine the evidence for themselves rather than suppressing their questions. His response in the next verses also shows that genuine skepticism should be willing to believe when the evidence satisfactorily answers its doubts.
The Bible and its claims hold up to all honest investigation. Its claims do not contradict reality. Honest reason and investigation generally point to truths of its claims that have sufficient evidence to believe, but we cannot verify firsthand. This leaves room for us to have faith in God. And as the author of Hebrews tells us:
"And without faith it is impossible to please Him, for he who comes to God must believe that He is and that He is a rewarder of those who seek Him."
(Hebrews 11:6)
While the resurrection requires a measure of faith to believe, when all the evidence is presented, as incredible as it is, the resurrection of Jesus is the most plausible explanation, given the events that happened. See The Bible Says article: "Did Jesus of Nazareth Rise from the Dead?"
Thomas's skepticism was mirrored by many who did not see and did not believe. So much so that the first generation rejected Jesus as their messiah. This reflected the biblical pattern; the first Adam rejected God's commands and the first generation out of Egypt rejected God's provision. According to Peter's assertion in Acts 3:19-21, had Israel believed and repented, Jesus would have returned and set up His messianic reign.
The first generation ended with a massive slaughter by the Romans. Between 67 and 73 AD the "Jewish Wars" were litigated in Israel. Jewish tradition holds that the Jews lost because of infighting and lack of collaboration. When Rome laid siege to Jerusalem, zealots set fire to the food supplies to force people to fight. The basic attitude of the zealots was "My way or death," similar to the attitude Jesus's disciples had before the Spirit opened their eyes.
In Gamla, the zealot headquarters in Galilee (only five miles or so from the sea of Galilee), an estimated four thousand jumped to their death rather than be captured. This occurred near the beginning of the Jewish Wars. The war ended when a little under a thousand zealots took their own lives rather than submit to Roman capture at Masada in 73 AD. We might view Thomas's attitude as a reflection of the general attitude of the zealots. The refusal of zealots to shift their dedication from "my way" to "God's way" sowed the seeds of destruction.
This also reflects Jesus's teaching. As He asserts in the Sermon on the Mount, the world's way of "I want my own way" is a broad path that leads to destruction. The alternative is a narrow gate with a difficult path that leads to life (Matthew 7:13-14). Life is connection with God's design, which requires submission to His will. The disciples learned this lesson, at long last, and as a result, changed the world. They can be an inspiration to us all, given their multiple failures and slowness to learn.