James 4:11-17 meaning
James 4:11-17 challenges those who are proud and comport themselves as though they are God—in charge of outcomes and better than everyone else—and exhorts them to recognize instead that only God is in control.
James has finished describing the process of repentance from being double-minded and at odds with God, and the rejoining of fellowship found through humility and forgiveness. He returns to practical, specific examples of how we can live rightly with one another. His focus continues to center on setting aside pride and the harmful actions against others it prompts within us:
Do not speak against one another, brethren. He who speaks against a brother or judges his brother, speaks against the law and judges the law; but if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law but a judge of it (v 11).
James's exhortation is for his readers to practice humility and love toward one another be placing themselves in their proper position in life. We are called to fulfill Christ's law of love by loving one another and God. Therefore, we should not speak against one another. This is to blame, which is the basic job description of the devil (James 4:7). The world system of the devil is a blame culture, applying blame to push others down to elevate self.
James addresses brethren, signaling to and reminding the believers to whom he writes that we are all fellow believers and family in Christ. He already said in Chapter 1 that the basic problem is "me"—our "own lust" that carries us away and leads us to sin and its consequence, which is death (James 1:14-15). The solution is to set aside this inner "wickedness" and replace it with "the word implanted" (James 1:21).
This letter may be one of the first New Testament books written, and it was written to Jews (James 1:1). This population would understand that "the word implanted" means Scripture. And at that point in the first century, Scripture was the law, which for Jews was the Old Testament.
There was evident division, partiality, and judgment occurring in the assembly to whom James writes. All were believers, but many were treating others as lesser-than. Many were inappropriately applying the blame-culture of judgment and accusation that is from the world. In James 2:3-4, James denounced the preferential treatment that was happening in this community,
"…and you pay special attention to the one who is wearing the fine clothes, and say, 'You sit here in a good place,' and you say to the poor man, 'You stand over there, or sit down by my footstool,' have you not made distinctions among yourselves, and become judges with evil motives?"
In James 2:6, he highlighted that the wealthy were taking the poor to court and prosecuting them. Here now he broaches the same problem, demonstrating how those who are speaking against and judging their fellow believers are sinning, acting as "judges with evil motives."
The person who speaks against a brother or judges his brother is in actual fact speaking against the law and judging the law. The Mosaic law commands to love one's neighbor as one's self (Leviticus 19:18). Paul asserts in Romans that when believers walk in the Spirit they fulfill the law (Romans 8:4). It is the Spirit who leads and empowers us, and when we follow Him, it results in fulfilling the Law; we are not capable of fulfilling the law on our own strength.
James was at the council of Jerusalem where it was decided that following the Law does not save anyone, nor should Gentile Christians submit to the Law in order to be saved (Acts 15:13-20). Rather, they should submit to the Spirit (Galatians 3:5, 5:16). But submission to the Spirit leads to "the whole Law" being fulfilled, which is "in one word, in the statement 'You shall love your neighbor as yourself'" (Galatians 5:14).
We are called to live in obedience to God's Spirit, not religious rituals, to produce the fruit of the Spirit and fulfill God's purpose for us. Christ validated the command to love our neighbor as the second greatest; the first greatest is to love God with all our being, both of which encompass the entire law.
The law James has referenced in this letter is "the perfect law, the law of liberty," which believers should focus on, acting out the teachings of Christ rather than simply hearing them (James 1:25). Christ fulfilled the law (Matthew 5:17). Believers fulfill the law of Christ by bearing one another's burdens (Galatians 6:2).
Again, a big theme in James's letter is to do what we know to be right (James 4:17, 2:26). In Chapter 2, James discussed fulfilling "the royal law," which can also be translated "the law of our King," Jesus (James 2:6). James is pointing to the teachings of Jesus, the Son of God and Messiah, whom God exalted to kingship over the earth because of His faithful obedience (Philippians 2:5-11).
The specific royal law James points to is, "You shall love your neighbor as yourself," and if you live this way, James says "you are doing well" (James 2:8) and that you "will be blessed in what [you do]" (James 1:25). The law of loving our neighbor was taught by Jesus, who showed in His teachings that the intention of God's commandments to the Israelites was to instruct them to love Him and to love other people. The Apostles Paul, Peter, and John echoed Christ's teaching of love (Galatians 5:14, 1 Peter 1:22, 1 John 3:11, 3:23, 4:21).
In the simplest of terms, we are doing what is right when we love God above all else and love other people equally to how we love ourselves.
Jesus also said, "There is no other commandment greater than these" (Mark 12:30-31) and "On these two commandments depend the whole Law and the Prophets" (Matthew 22:40). He was quoting the Old Testament (Deuteronomy 6:5, Leviticus 19:18), distilling the whole point down to these two "commandments" or "laws." Jesus emphasized the importance of loving others at the Last Supper, the night before He died on the cross, telling the twelve disciples,
"A new commandment I give to you, that you love one another, even as I have loved you, that you also love one another. By this all men will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another."
(John 13:34-35)
James likewise is pointing to the law of the King, Jesus, to stress to his readers that they need to love one another. He earlier warned those who are not acting lovingly,
"So speak and so act as those who are to be judged by the law of liberty. For judgment will be merciless to one who has shown no mercy; mercy triumphs over judgment."
(James 2:12-13)
This rebuke is for those who are not speaking and acting with love toward one another. They need to wake up and remember that they will be judged by Jesus according to how well they loved one another. Some of his readership seem to be living as though they won't be judged.
It is very true we will not be judged or condemned to eternal separation from God, being made alive in Christ, simply through our faith in Him (John 3:14-16, 10:27-30, Colossians 3:3-4), but we will be judged by Jesus when He returns. This is noted throughout the New Testament many times over (Matthew 16:27, 2 Corinthians 5:9-10, Romans 14:10-12, 1 Corinthians 3:8-15, 4:3-5).
These unloving believers were actually speaking against and judging the law of love, which is to say they were flouting Jesus's commandments and acting disobediently, even rebelliously, against how God desires they treat other believers. They are instead putting themselves in the place of God.
This ties back to the first ten verses of this chapter, where James rebukes them for their in-fighting, their selfish motives, their friendship with the world and unfaithfulness toward God (James 4:1-10).
His point to his readers is that they should not try to assert supremacy or power over one another. Jesus is the judge and James has described the judgment of Christ in Chapter 2. The law is God's will for us, generally fulfilled when we love one another as ourselves and love God above all. This is a call to understand our proper place in this life. This letter has regularly dealt with some believers lording over others, putting others down, living like the world where hierarchy and status organize how people are treated.
James is warning these readers not to speak against one another. Do not judge your brother. We will all be judged one day; we are not the judges. Jesus stated explicitly that our own standard of judgment will be established by how we judge others (Matthew 7:1-2). Jesus went on to instruct His disciples that when they see faults in others, it means they have the fault themselves (Matthew 7:3). If you just stop here, you might say, "James is creating judgment for himself, because he is judging these fellow believers."
But Jesus went on to tell His disciples who see sin in others to first deal with their own sin. Then they are clear to help their brothers deal with their sin (Matthew 7:5). But first, Jesus taught His disciples to decide whether their brother is willing to hear what is "holy," which is the "pearl" of corrective truth (Matthew 7:6).
It is reasonable to presume James had ingested this teaching. He is, therefore, complimenting those receiving this letter. In giving them corrective words, James assesses that they have sufficient wisdom to recognize that correction is holy and precious. They will not be like the dogs that bite the hand feeding them or the hog rolling their pearls of corrective wisdom in the mud.
If we do speak against and judge one another as a means of seeking to control them, we are going against God's commands/law. By putting ourselves in God's place, we are once again living out opposition to God Himself, which is the sin of pride. And as we saw in James 4:6, God resists the proud.
James writes plainly that if you judge the law, you are not a doer of the law but a judge of it (v 11). The believers who put down their brothers and seek to control them—while claiming they were somehow fulfilling God's commands—are not obeying God's commands (not a doer of the law) but have tried to put themselves above God's commands (but a judge of it—the law). It is in effect what Satan tried to do before he was cast out of heaven (Isaiah 14:12-15). We are trying to make ourselves God or are trying to assert ourselves above God.
James reminds his readers of the real order of things:
There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the One who is able to save and to destroy; but who are you who judge your neighbor? (v 12).
There is only one Person in authority. God. Only God is the Lawgiver, the one who is perfectly righteous and apart from whom no order of right conduct or good actions can exist. Only God can tell us what is right and wrong. The first five of the Ten Commandments basically make this point, that God makes the rules. (The fifth commandment tells children too young to understand this to obey their parents in the meanwhile).
The last five of the Ten Commandments basically tell us the main things God desires, the primary parameters that are His rules. And that amounts to loving our neighbors as ourselves. Jesus summarized this by saying the two greatest commandments are to love God with all our being and to love our neighbor as ourselves (Matthew 22:37-39). He said the entire "Law and Prophets" depend on these two commandments (Matthew 22:40).
So when we sit in God's chair, we are violating the first and greatest commandment. And when we apply that usurped authority to condemn others, we are violating the second. James asks but who are you who judge your neighbor? (v 12). You are not God, not the Lawgiver, not the Judge—there's only One of those. You are not able to save and to destroy (v 12); there's only One who can do either of those things.
So then, who are you? You're a brother. Other believers are your fellow family members, also brought into God's family by God's grace. You're a servant. You're a sinner saved from sin and called to walk in the resurrection life of Jesus. You have the opportunity to walk in Christ's resurrection power, and to imitate Him by submitting to God and following the Holy Spirit's leadership.
Our job is not to judge or dictate to others. We are not to live under an illusion that we control others, but to serve and to love them. There are only three things we control: who we believe, the perspective we adopt, and the actions we take. What perspective we choose will be informed by who we believe, and our perspectives inform our actions. To have faith in ourselves is to be proud, which God opposes (James 4:6). To adopt a perspective that we control others and have authority over them is to believe an illusion. And to act on that perspective leads to our own destruction.
Even those called to lead from positions of authority and to teach in the church are explicitly told to carry out their job with love (Ephesians 4:15, 1 Corinthians 13:1-3, 2 Timothy 2:24-25, 1 Thessalonians 2:7-8). In the previous chapter, James described the kind of men his readers should listen to, men who teach heavenly wisdom and are gentle, merciful peacemakers (James 3:13-18).
James now provides an example of someone who acts as though they are in charge of the outcomes of life, rather than God:
Come now, you who say, "Today or tomorrow we will go to such and such a city, and spend a year there and engage in business and make a profit" (v 13).
The premise and problem in this example are stated first. James addresses you who say the following statement. He addresses this type of person with an incredulous Come now, bringing their attention to the irrational approach they are taking to life.
These people have a life philosophy, put to words as, "Today or tomorrow (planning time) we will go to such and such a city (planning a location, it does not matter where), and spend a year there and engage in business (planning investment) and make a profit (planning success)" (v 13).
The grammar of this plan is confident and sure. The businessman speaks as though these things will absolutely happen just as he says, because he says so. This man thinks his business will make a profit wherever and whenever he executes his plan. He is living an illusion of control. This is another application of believing in self (pride) and adopting the illusory perspective of sitting in God's chair of authority.
James will cut down this kind of thinking. It is not that making plans or pursuing ambition is evil; the problem emerges when we put ourselves in the place of God, and replace faith in God (humility) with faith in self (pride). When we think we are in charge of the outcome, we have made a mistake. We are living a false reality, we are following an illusion that will eventually crash into reality.
James counters the perspective of illusory certainty by pointing to an observable reality: the frailty and uncertainty of human life:
Yet you do not know what your life will be like tomorrow. You are just a vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes away (v 14).
This is a true statement which can be applied to any human who has ever lived: Yet you do not know what your life will be like tomorrow (v 14). We have no idea what will happen tomorrow or even today. It is beyond our knowledge and control. A war might begin, a war might end, the car might break down, a health issue may be discovered. We might drop dead of a heart attack.
James may have in mind the wisdom of King Solomon,
"Do not boast about tomorrow,
For you do not know what a day may bring forth."
(Proverbs 27:1)
To boast about our future is irrational. We simply do not know the future. We can work hard, we can plan, but we are not in control of the outcome.
James tells the arrogant businessman, You are just a vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes away (v 14). Our lives are short. We are just a vapor. We are just a bit of mist in the morning, gone when the sun rises. Steam from a boiling pot, here now, gone the next moment.
As King David put it, man is "like a mere breath; His days are like a passing shadow" (Psalm 144:4).
Solomon spoke of the human lifespan as being "fleeting":
"Enjoy life with the woman whom you love all the days of your fleeting life which He has given to you under the sun; for this is your reward in life and in your toil in which you have labored under the sun."
(Ecclesiastes 9:9)
The Hebrew root word translated "your fleeting" is "hebel" which appears over thirty times in Ecclesiastes, and is a primary theme. It is most often translated "vanity" or "futility." The word "hebel" refers to a vapor, and most of Ecclesiastes speaks of trying to hold vapor in one's hand, which is a futile endeavor.
As an Israelite who knew Scripture, James might have had this image of "hebel" in mind when he wrote that our lives are like a vapor, something you see for a short time that soon vanishes into the air. To cling to life as though it is permanent is also living an illusion. The wise thing to do is to make full use of this life to prepare for the next, when we will take on immortality (1 Corinthians 15:53).
The human living in this life, on this earth, appears for a little while and then vanishes away (v 14), and not a single day was ever fully in our control. The fact that we cannot control what happens, whatever we try to do, is worth remembering. Likewise, it is worth remembering that it is God who truly is sovereign over any outcome. Our appropriate stewardship is to wisely manage the three things we actually control and:
- Trust God, adopting humility/recognizing reality that He is God, not us (James 4:7).
- Set aside our own inner wickedness (and false perspectives) and replace them with the embedded word, which means adopting true perspectives (James 1:21).
- Apply these true perspectives by living them out, which is to do the word, not merely speak it (James 1:22).
James explains what this proud person living the illusion of control ought to say and how they ought to think:
Instead, you ought to say, "If the Lord wills, we will live and also do this or that" (v 15).
Instead, the wise perspective to take and the way to frame our plans is that we ought to say, "If the Lord wills" (v 15). If God allows it; if this is what God wants and ensures will happen. God knows all things and is sovereign over all things. We can still plan, but should recognize we are acting within God's plan.
God is in control, and in His sovereignty has allowed His creations to make moral choices. And many of those choices are against His design, and thus bring evil into the world. God permits this, but places boundaries. The pain and suffering which Job experienced came from Satan, but Satan had to ask God's permission first (Job 1:7-12).
God allowed the suffering, but in the process gave Job an immense benefit. Job came to know God by faith, and gained an eternal perspective. In the end, Job observed of God, "I know that You can do all things, And that no purpose of Yours can be thwarted" (Job 42:1-6). Nothing takes God by surprise. And if God wants something to happen, it will happen (Isaiah 14:27). One of the great themes of Scripture is that God turns what was meant for evil to good (Genesis 50:20, Romans 8:28).
In the knowledge that God is sovereign, we can plan how we will live and also what we will do, whether this or that. Whatever our ambitions, hopes, and dreams, we should always acknowledge that the outcome rests on If the Lord wills.
James makes his deeper point clear; he is not merely criticizing conceited merchants for thinking too highly of their business acumen. He’s condemning arrogance and boasting as a whole:
But as it is, you boast in your arrogance; all such boasting is evil (v 16)
This ties back to a key theme in this chapter that God gives favor to the humble but opposes the proud (James 4:6). James is providing motivation to his readers to live out their faith; there are real consequences at stake. Having told his readers what they ought to say, he reminds them that they do not do as they ought. What they really think and do, currently, as it is, is boast in their arrogance.
Throughout this letter James has taken to task the wealthy who look down on the poor (James 1:9-11, 2:1-7), the hypocrites who boast in their faith and don't follow it up with action (James 2:14-26), and the teachers in their assembly who are sinful and divisive (James 3:1, 14-16). He has admonished the proud men starting fights and causing conflict due to their bad motives, who are living as friends of the world and enemies to God (James 4:1-4). Pride, arrogance, all such boasting—it is evil. It is the problem.
The poison of arrogance is that it makes us feel as though we are better than other people and better than God Himself. It is a lie that leads us to think we are in control of our lives. The Greek word translated arrogance is also found in 1 John 2:16, where it is translated "boastful pride" and is presented as one of a triad of the world's basic characteristics, along with "lust of the eyes" and "lust of the flesh."
Accordingly, this arrogance is in the very nature of the world's system. To believe we are in control, to place ourselves in a position of superiority over others, leads to boasting, which is the promotion of self and the diminishing of others. As James puts it, all such boasting is evil (v 16). It is the opposite of humility and submission to God, which James urged them to practice just a few verses earlier (James 4:6-10).
The chapter concludes with a powerful examination of sin. Sin is not merely what we do that strays from God's good design, it is also our choice to not do what we know to be good:
Therefore, to one who knows the right thing to do and does not do it, to him it is sin (v 17).
James addresses any individual—to one—within the framework of their moral knowledge, their ability to understand the good choice in each situation—who knows the right thing to do (v 17)—and in spite of knowing the right thing to do (v 17), they rebel against this choice and remain inert. They do not do it, they do not do the right thing which they know full well to be the right thing to do. They encounter an opportunity where they can make the right choice and they say, “No.” This is quite simply sin. James is clear that to this person with knowledge of the right thing to do, to him it is sin (v 17) to fail to act rightly.
The word Therefore points back to the preceding arguments or statements, often building a case. The Therefore takes what was spoken previously and points to a conclusion or an implication based on the prior conclusions. In the immediate context, it would seem James is referring to his correction of the arrogant men who boast in themselves, instead of acknowledging God as sovereign.
Going further back it would include speaking against brothers and judging them, which is again someone putting themselves in the place of God and lacking humility and love for others. Even further back, James rebuked those who were living in friendship with the world and its sinful values, which is a hostile betrayal to God.
James may be referring to all these things. They are each consistent with his overarching rebuke of the believers in this church who are living contrary to their faith. He is calling them to live with integrity, to integrate their actions with their faith (synergy—Greek, "synergeo" faith working together with actions, James 2:22).
In calling sinful anyone who knows the right thing to do and does not do it (v 17), James creates an answer to the natural question stemming from James 3:1, where James said, "Let not many of you become teachers" because teachers will "incur a stricter judgment."
The natural question stemming from this statement is, "Then why would anyone teach?" The answer is, "If you know it is the right thing to do." Thus, teachers should do their teaching from a position of calling, not from a position of seeking attention or honor from others.
The right thing to do includes the believer who not only wishes their suffering brother well, but loves their neighbor by giving help however they can (James 2:14). If we see someone in need, we give them a blanket. If someone is hungry, we feed them. If someone is wandering off into sin, we lovingly correct them back to the truth (James 5:19).
We act upon our faith. We trust in God and do as He has taught us what is right. To adopt a perspective that is right and true should lead us to acting upon what we know is right and true. The Lord wants us to be active, to do the "good works, which God prepared beforehand so that we would walk in them" (Ephesians 2:10).
We do what God has taught us to do by loving Him and loving others as much as we love ourselves. In doing so, not only are we avoiding sin, but we will find God's blessing, reward, and mercy (James 1:25, 12, 2:5, 13).
Having read this far into James's letter, every reader is without excuse and on the hook to do the right thing. They may have thought they could plead ignorance before, but they are now informed. They are all now the one who knows the right thing to do because James has taught it to them. James has been thorough in the wrong things they need to stop doing and the right things they need to do instead.
In the following final chapter, James will continue to admonish those exploiting others, speak of the coming judgment, and share wisdom concerning prayer.